Breaststroke and Butterfly: When Swimmers Are Ready
Breaststroke and Butterfly: When Swimmers Are Ready
Both strokes demand timing that freestyle and backstroke do not. That is why they come after, not before.
Book swim lessons →Once a swimmer has freestyle and backstroke working, breaststroke and butterfly are the natural next territory. They are also noticeably harder, and for a reason that is worth understanding: both are timing strokes.
In freestyle and backstroke the arms alternate continuously, which is forgiving. In breaststroke and butterfly everything happens simultaneously and in sequence, so if the timing is wrong the swimmer stops moving entirely. There is no partial credit.
These strokes fail loudly
A rough freestyle still moves a swimmer down the pool. A breaststroke with the timing wrong goes nowhere at all, which is frustrating rather than dangerous, and it is why patience matters here.
What each stroke demands
Very different challenges, both requiring a solid base first.
Breaststroke timing
Pull, breathe, kick, glide, in that order every time. Getting the sequence wrong is the single biggest cause of a breaststroke that does not move.
The breaststroke kick
A whip kick that is unlike anything in the other strokes, and often the hardest single movement in swimming to teach.
Butterfly rhythm
A body undulation driven from the chest and hips, with two kicks per arm cycle, that has to become instinctive rather than deliberate.
Butterfly strength
Both arms recovering over the water at once is genuinely demanding, which is why swimmers usually need a certain physical readiness.
Core control
Both strokes rely on the body working as a connected unit rather than arms and legs operating independently.
Patience
These take longer than the first two strokes, and progress is less linear. That is normal.
How to know a swimmer is ready
The honest answer is that readiness is about competence rather than age. A swimmer who is comfortable in deep water, can swim a sustained freestyle with side breathing and holds a solid backstroke has the foundation these strokes need.
Physical readiness matters for butterfly in particular. It asks for a level of shoulder strength and coordination that younger swimmers often simply do not have yet, and pushing it early tends to produce a struggling, discouraged swimmer rather than a fast one.
Breaststroke can often be introduced a little earlier, because the timing can be practised slowly and the kick worked on separately at the wall long before the full stroke comes together.
How they are taught
Slowly, in parts, with a lot of drill work.
Kick in isolation
Both strokes have distinctive kicks that are practised at the wall or with a board until the movement pattern is right.
Arms in isolation
The pull pattern practised separately, often standing in shallow water for breaststroke or with a board for butterfly.
Slow motion timing
Putting the parts together deliberately slowly, so the sequence becomes correct before it becomes fast.
Short distances
Building up in very short repeats, because both strokes done badly for long distances just embeds the errors.
Do all swimmers need them?
For water safety purposes, no. Freestyle, backstroke, floating and treading water cover everything that matters for staying safe in the water, and a swimmer who has those is genuinely competent.
Breaststroke and butterfly matter for swimmers moving toward competitive swimming, swim team, or simply for the enjoyment and challenge of learning them. Breaststroke also has real practical value because it is efficient, keeps the head up easily and is comfortable for long distances.
Our program covers refined stroke technique in the later levels, alongside treading water, flip turns and diving, for swimmers who want to keep progressing beyond the safety foundation.
Frequently asked questions
What age should a child learn breaststroke and butterfly?
Why is breaststroke so hard?
Is butterfly necessary?
Which should be learned first?
Do you teach all four strokes?
Related reading
Keep progressing past the basics
For swimmers ready to go further, refined technique is where swimming stops being a safety skill and starts being a sport.
Register for swim lessons →